Critical Examination Essay

Elaine Kenny English 1121 Mentor Shal Mar 26, 2010 An Research of Vaillant's " We need to Retain the Disease Concept of Alcoholism” George Vaillant, M. M., psychiatrist and Director of Adult Creation at Harvard University, is usually an expert in the field of alcoholism and has published extensively on the subject. In August 1990, the Harvard Medical School Mental Well being Letter printed his article " We ought to Retain the Disease Concept of Addiction to alcohol, ” by which he mentioned that addiction to alcohol can deservingly be known as disease because long-term maltreatment of liquor creates health concerns that are directly attributable to incapacity and even fatality (544) and this classifying this as a disease would help successful treatment (545). (The first a lot of sentences with this introduction provides the reader the attribution from the article as well as information about the topic that Vaillant wrote about. The declaration that follows illustrates the main idea or thesis of the the article. ) Vaillant argued that the perception of alcoholism while solely a behavior was incorrect, happened by individuals who lacked direct experience with treatment for alcoholism, and was dependent on the worth judgments of " fewer competent people” (543). (What follows may be the student-writer's thesis which is an evaluation of the success of the article. )Dr. Vaillant's essay is beneficial and influential. He effectively compares dependency on alcohol to various other disease techniques and credibly addresses the objections of his detractors with common sense and modest emotional is attractive. However , he does not lend much credit to other disciplines such as psychotherapy which have been also effective in the alcoholic's overall restoration, and his failing to look at a multidisciplinary way of treatment might lead to some visitors to dismiss his normally excellent article as one-sided or partisan.

Kenny -- 2 Dr . Vaillant had written to address the published views of different experts who have disagreed while using medical model of alcoholism. (The paragraph commences...

the publication Essay